AU Interactive

Google Knol - Google Finally Gets into Content

Google owns knowledgeLate last week Google announced Google Knol - a shot across the bow for every single publisher out there. For years Google has been claiming that they are in the game only to “organize the world’s information”, yet Knol is a play to actually create Google’s own authoritative content. This sounds a lot like Google is throwing Wikipedia, Mahalo, and its own index into one giant pot (and labeling it with an assenine moniker).

It’s kind of interesting that Knol is supposed to stand for “unit of knowledge”. It doesn’t get any more clear that Google is trying to make everything under the sun into a commodity - all to be exploited via contextual (and soon behaviorally-targeted) ads.

As Aaron points out, Google will probably start ranking Knol in the SERPS. With this move, they’ve just overstepped an important boundary. As an independent web publisher, I can say that this move gives me all the more reason to distrust the Google borg. Google has been gobbling up all the players as it moves along the value chain, and here they’ve just overstepped a very significant boundary.

robojiannis said,

December 17, 2007 @ 1:43 pm

But do you really think Knol poses a threat to wikipedia (wikipedia being the main competitor)?
The role of the author (Knol says it wants “…to highlight authors”) is not such an important aspect in the social web (nor in the web in general).
And apart from that, will a number of experts provide better information than the collective wisdom?

Markus said,

December 17, 2007 @ 1:58 pm

Since Wikipedia already ranks for everything, it will probably continue to do so, but Knols could appear right alongside, pushing everyone else down.

I disagree that roles of authors are unimportant. I’ll take a small number of experts over “the masses” anyday (for most topics I care about).

Leave a Comment