AdBrite is actually a CPM ad network (you pay for impressions, not clicks) so it’s not PPC but I will share my horrible experiences with them anyway since I tested AdBrite along with the other PPC systems in this series.
I setup an account with them several months ago and put in a very low CPM price for a single ad – at the time my maximum amount was too low to run anything on their partner sites, so nothing really happened. Since nothing was happening, I sort of forgot about my ad in their system.
Fast forward a few months later – I saw a massive amount of traffic to our site. I looked at the stats to try to figure out where it was all coming from and the referrers were all strange foreign sites (lots of Korean sites) – hundreds of them – most looked like foreign versions of MFA sites – some were not even sites, but cloaked pages, non-pages, ad pages, frames – just complete garbage. But they were sending our site a ridiculous amount of traffic.
Confused, I started digging deeper and logged into my AdBrite account. Lo and behold, my ads had gone active 3 days ago and I was being charged $100 per day for a total of $300. So I went from $0/day and 0 visitors to $100/day (my maximum) and thousands of visitors.
I called AdBrite and they told me that they had just changed some things in their system to “allow more exposure for our advertisers”. I asked them to refund my money since I was not told about this change, and all the traffic I had received was from spammy sites. They sent me the following response:
I spoke with you today regarding the clicks your ad received. We upgraded our system to optimize the ad servers and on Thursday we introduced those new filters, which is why you saw the increase in traffic. Looking at your network, it doesn’t look like there was any fraudulent activity going on, but you can send us any statistics and sites that you would like us to review. Let us know if you have any further questions.
I then proceeded to study my stats and make screenshots of the reports. Fun facts: A lot of the top referrers were not even websites but blank pages, 100% ad pages, redirects, etc. 50% of the traffic was coming from a single IP in Korea! When I contacted AdBrite again with the stats, they referred me to their quality control department and asked me to provide specifics, which I did. This was August 21st.
I followed up several times with them and was told that they were investigating the matter. One whole month later on September 22nd, I received the following email:
Thanks for writing. We have concluded the necessary research for the network ad in question. There was total of $101.64 invalid clicks generated in your network campaign. The invalid clicks has been refunded back to your credit card as requested.
So after a whole month of “investigation” I only got 1/3 of my money back. The methods they used to determine clicks? Who knows. Needless to say, I am not happy. My opinion of AdBrite: STAY AWAY FROM THEM.
As a bonus, on the bottom of their emails they usually had the following:
Ticket Details
===================
Ticket ID: DFU-######
Department: Online Support
Priority: Low
Status: Closed
So I’m glad they considered my click fraud request LOW priority and considered it CLOSED even before it was resolved.
- PPC Network Overview
- Part 1: Google AdWords
- Part 2: Yahoo Search Marketing
- Part 3: MSN AdCenter
- Part 4: Looksmart
- Part 5: Adbrite
This site runs on Thesis. Yours should too
Are you a blogger that doesn't understand a lot of PHP? Are you looking for a theme with Flexibility, Easy Customizations, Rock Solid SEO, and Outstanding Support?
If so Thesis is for you. Using Thesis you will have more control over layout and design than you ever thought possible. Simply point and click.
For more advanced users Thesis has an intelligent customization system that uses hooks. Using hooks you can use Thesis across all of your sites and never tell it was the same theme. Watch the Thesis Video Tour.
{ 1 trackback }
{ 40 comments… read them below or add one }
In order to prevent this in the future, you might want to try using AdBrite’s Geo Targeting.
I
Oh, you can rest assured there will be no “in the future” with AdBrite.
I have tried adbrite on both publisher and advertiser sides and must say that the experience was horrible. Their admin interface is pityful and half of the time I have no idea what I bought or sold. No idea how to turn things off, etc. So as Markus says, there will no “in the future” for me either.
Very unfortunate too.
I can report a very similar bad experience with the Adbrite network ads. They run ads on junkie high traffic file hosting sites like 2kdown.com and badongo.net, and charge $.15 per click from them. The traffic is very low quality, and as far as I can tell there is no option at all to block sites.
You have a very good review on adwords, adbrites and so on. Recently, I came across this Kumomo.com which allow users to buy and sell ad space online for free. Maybe you should have a look and tell us how is it doing. I understand that they are using booking system to book an ad space.
I must agree, I have bad experiences with Adbrite too, their web administration is not really online, their actions always need review, that means LONG time… adbrite NEVER AGAIN… NEVER AGAIN!
And yes, their traffic is really junk… its true
You really got into the detail for many ad marketing providers. Every ad system has its pros and cons. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
I have joined the AdBrite market place some time ago. As I have recently noticed, they have removed my website PIXEL TEMPLATES (Category: Arts & Entertainment > Visual Arts) from their site directory. That doesn’t make any sense, thus advertisers will never find me on their advertising platform. So, it is getting difficult for me as a publisher to reach potential advertisers. Until now, I have not received any response from AdBrite on this concern. I believe they fear I would get too many free leads from people browsing their site directory. Secondly, AdBrite does no longer display any ads on my website. This said, their slogan “Monetize your website with AdBrite” does not apply.
I have posted some comments directly on my website.
http://www.pixel-templates.com/about/
And yes, it’s true. Their Site Directory contains a lot of junk, fake and adult websites. However, if more and more interesting blog sites and informative websites will jump-in, this could become an interesting alternative to Google, Yahoo and other CPC advertising systems.
I especially like the idea of flat rate ads and CPM ads, since the thread of click fraud is non-existent for these advertising methods. Being able to define your own pricing structure as a publisher is much more liberal and makes this marketplace more dynamic than any other advertising platform out there.
graphically & sincerely,
Marc Klein
There is another article posted on Graywolf’s SEO blog:
http://www.wolf-howl.com/22/adbrite-review/
I put adbrite up on my website in hopes to promote it. A couple things to note: many of the websites that my ad was on, were JUNK sites or were on a .RU (Russian) domain, which would redirect to a .COM. Many of these websites didn’t even have ads on them when I went and manually looked. Several more had “Page coming soon” links throughout the site. Who knows where the traffic was actually coming from (Note the above post about the trojan). The bottom line: ADBRITE IS A SCAM – AVOID THIS AT ALL COST!
They charged me for 100’s of clicks on the first of the month. Funny part is my campaign has been deleted since the middle of last month. No response from them yet!
Check my test with AdBrite:
http://fundszine.com/77-adbrite-fraudulent-publishers/
http://fundszine.com/83-adbrite-fraudulent-publishers-the-results/
http://fundszine.com/85-adbrite-fraudulent-publishers-the-conclusion/
I also was spammed by various fraudulent publishers when running my CPM campaign.
I hope it will be helpful for anybody who is looking to work with AdBrite.
Early this month I bought what I thought was two weeks of advertising with Adbrite text ads on one site for $20. Their stats say I had 100 clicks. I bought what I thought was two weeks – the invoice said “Your ad will run for 14 consecutive days” but buried below that was “recurrent until cancelled”. HuH? how can they advertise “14 days of advertising” and keep billing you? Gross misrepresentation if ever I saw one. They took another $20 out of my credit card the other day. When I logged into my account it says “no campaign current” so I couldn’t cancel anything anyway. It takes 9 steps (count them) to cancel your spots and then you have to send them an email on their “Contact us” – which they never reply to even though the auto response tagged it as “Urgent”. I’m still waiting for a reply to my second email demanding a refund. TOTAL BUNCH OF CROOKS and I wouldn’t recommend them to anyone. Oh yeah…the traffic they sent is torrent sites/porn and Viagra. Well done ADBRITE you bunch of assholes!
We published ads on our site from Adbrite for a bit. After a few months we noticed some of the ads weren’t working correctly and once we contacted them about the issue they decided to close our account claiming click fraud and we lost more then $700 in ad revenue. They stated that we must find IP information from our website to prove that these were valid clicks. Of course we have no way of telling which IPs clicked on their ads because they have no tracking included in their service. I don’t know why they couldn’t strip out the fraudulent clicks, if there were any. Basically, we are forced to believe whatever they claim and take the loss. Rest assured, we removed their script and closed our account with them.
Hey Best, you have the most recent experience with them. You said you “lost $700″ in ad revenue, do you mean you had to pay them or your monthly/weekly/daily revenue just decreased by $700?
Thanks for your help
Simple thing to get around this is to select the exact sites you want to advertise on with Adbrite.
Very confusing, so what is the best CPC beside adsense?
Ouch! That sounds really bad. And I just signed up with AdBrite as a publisher, since AdSense isn’t an option for me. I wonder…
Hey Best, you have the most recent experience with them.
purnima
———————
See how pwc’s looked at the internal audit
http://www.auditqualitypwc.blogspot.com/
Their admin interface is pityful and half of the time I have no idea what I bought or sold.
purnima
——————-
we can find a very good job with no scam
http://www.bestjobs4you.blogspot.com
I decided to try AdBrite and I was appalled when I woke up the next day to find that they went ahead and put graphic porn ads on my non-adult websites. They have not provided any explanation, so I immediately changed my ads back to Google.
adbrite generates nothing but tonnes of worthless traffic, you pay for nothing. I will stick to adword although they are charging us a crazy fees, but bottomline is that adword works!
i was scammed too by adbrite,,,assholes are constantly taking or trying to take money off my card..anyone have any ideas on how too get this money bk or who process,s there credit card stuff
Adbrite advertising is a joke, not worth the money.
what is the sense of getting 2000 visitors/day and 0 conversion. that tells you it’s all fraud or junk automated traffic not seen by humans.
I too, had a bad experience with adbrite as a publisher. Stay away from them!
Unfortunately i don’t have a success story but i will tell you my own experience with them.
In short, Adbrite ripped me off!!! I decided to give them a try and advertise my website in their marketplace and after i signed up and created my campaign then a while later i was trying to do some edits and i paused it but even though i did they kept charging my credit card for over 3 days after and i e-mailed their support million of times to get a refund with no use :(
Moreover, the quality of traffic they bring is useless cheap junk traffic.
Whether you are going to advertise in their marketplace or monetize your website traffic..Do yourself a favor and STAY AWAY FROM THEM!
Abdrite is 50% good and 50% unknown….They did take away lot of my clicks for unknown reason and I completely stopped using their service…6 months later they send me my 500$ paycheck which I just received today…Maybe they want me back but I am not going back to them until google adsense bans me for life..
Adbrite is JOKE. I had a publisher account with them. I have a site which is targeted to Indian customers and the site has ONLY and ONLY Indian visitors since the TLD is .in
I get on an average 35 unique visitors (Approximately 1000 UV a month). My traffic generated $2 in month of May, $3 in June and then around $1.50 in July. Needless to say that it sucked to see such a low conversion. Never mind, since beginning of August, the ads disappeared from my site. I waited for 3 weeks and finally contacted Adbrite to know whats wrong.
They replied back saying, my account was flagged since a lot of false impressions and clicks were generated on my account.
I really laughed like hell. What kind of idiots would say that a lot of false impressions and clicks were generated looking at the revenue I earned for 3 months …
They asked for my 3 months stats alongwith information about refers and IPs that visited my site. Not only that, they asked me to send them a copy of my driving license or Passport and latest utility bill.
I told them to kiss my ass .. they replied : Since you were unable to provide any proof, your account will not be re-activated. I again replied back that take those $5 up their cheeks. Finally they got the message.
Adbrite sucks like anything. I don’t care about losing money, but I am so pissed about being called a cheat/fraud. Man, do they even use their brain at all before sending such nonsense statements??
I mean, with 1000 uniques a month and a few clicks, I earned $2 and they crying about that too .. What a shame!
Adbrite sucks badly!!
I just signed up with Adrbite yesterday and the fact it takes moe than 3 hours for ads to be activated is a big NONO to me. Who got 3 hours to waste waiting for some code “to activate”… this is 2008. So, thank you all coz I defitely closed the publisher account and won’t even go to the advertizer given your insights.
I have had decent experience with adbrite in the past when I had a website that generated around 15,000 impressions daily. But that website went downhill now I am starting a new one and using Abrite as a form of advertising.
adbrite is a scam it ruins your search engine ranking because you have to link to the ads. which to me means they are just rigged. Look at how well their site or sites that we dont know of run. Im sure they wont be telling us. I just put adbrite on my site an hour ago and now am about to pull the ads before their spiders ruin the site
I tried running AdBrite on my blog this past week. At first I ran the text-only ads for a couple of days to see how they would do. I only had one ad pop up and that was a spam site disguised as a competing site! I don’t want to subject my readers to that kind of garbage, so I took it down immediately. Afterwards I tried the default text & graphics ads and no ads popped up at all…even after 12 or so hours! I finally decided to give up on AdBrite and just stick with AdSense for the time being.
I had similar awful experiences advertising with Adbrite. Just setting up my campaigns was a nightmare because if they disapprove your ads for any reason they completely delete them and you have to totally remake and resubmit them from scratch every time, which I had to do about 5 times. After all that, I got an email saying my ads have been declined due to “drug promotion” (i sell vitamin supplements).
After my ads were declined, the next due I find charges from Adbrite totalling about $300. After telling me my ads were declined they decided to run them anyway without telling me.
Furthermore, after wasting $300 I recieved 0 conversions from Adbrite. Taking a closer lookg at the traffic sources, I found they were all from torrent websites and other garbage. Adbrite aka Adshit is definetly not comparable to other PPC sites like Adwords/Yahoo Marketing/Adcenter. Stay away from it.
I advertised on adbrite a while back – still have two identical ad campaigns! Both paused. Can’t seem to find a way to delete them?
Lost all input (ads, etc.) when they disallowed ads to site with pop-up asking for e-mail. Fixed that, started campaign all over with all ads. Server got disconnected before budget and bidding phase. Connected again, no campaign. So I created it again. After a while, BOTH identical campaigns running! Double the clicks, double the money. Keep getting reached budget, please increase budget e-mails. 1000 clicks a day, NO SALES. Bad traffic.
I paused both campaigns, still get “reached budget, please increase” e-mails 4 days after pausing? No money on my account, though?
I’m sorry to say, their admin is bad, their traffic is not good at all. Probably not targeted at all – don’t know how they identify the sites they advertise on.
I WILL STAY AWAY FROM THEM.
This is really interesting. I was planning to get some traffic from adbright. Now after reading this, its making me think. How about if you buy from an individual website.
I don’t find adbrite particularly effecient. I don’t see what I can do with them that adsense doesn’t offer.
Ain’t wasting my time there
I agree with you they had bad support team
I had very bad experience with AdBrite also. I ended up getting most of my money back but wasted hours and hours of my time. I saw some guys over on the forums at AdNetworks.net that had similar experiences with them and also. I think I have had enough of this PPC crap and maybe even Ad Networks in general.
Please stay away from them. They are thieves and they will run with your money! I’m currently in a battle to get my $200 back that they took from my credit card although I had no ads running. I joined in April, run a few ads that quickly reached $109. My credit card company stopped my credit card due to a fraudulant activity so Adbride decided to delete my ads immediately when they couldn’t debit my card. They kept sending me reminder emails informing me that they were unable to debit my credit card. I emailed back to tell them what had happened with my credit card and I was waiting for a new card. When I got my card back, I entered my new credit card details to pay the amount I owed them. I thought that it was the end of the story. A couple of weeks later, I received an email that I had gone over my daily budget. I emailed them back to say that I didn’t have any ads running so I couldn’t have gone over my daily budget. They emailed back saying that they had made a mistake as the ads were paused. My mistake was not to have replied and say that I had no ads running for the 2nd time! Beginning of June they debited $200 from my credit card. I couldn’t believe it. I’ve been fighting ever since with them to get my money back. It’s unbelievable that they can get away with this! I don’t know what to do next. Sorry for the long rant by I’m lost with these people!
ADBRITE IS NOTHING BUT SCAM……….I had joined as a publisher since May 2009. My daily earnings were about 42 cents and they disqualified my website for same invalid clicks and invalid traffic. they had sent me an e-mail to use SPOTT as banner exchange to drive more traffic which i did put on my website and in a few days it was showing all type of adult website on it…….inspite of dealing with it for few more days there was no traffic exchange and I used other traffic exchange programs which did drive traffic but Adbrite does not want to pay me that’s why is coming up with all bullshit my 3 month earning is around $22 which I do not mind losing but I have lost countless hours dealing with their bullshit…..
Adbrite is ok if you have enough traffic